Carney Government Revives Rare Parliamentary Mechanism for Major Bill C-39

Date:

The Carney administration intends to employ a parliamentary mechanism that has not been utilized since the Harper administration to prioritize the examination of its recent major projects legislation.

Shortly after the introduction of Bill C-39, the government initiated a move to send it to a “legislative committee,” a procedure used for some of the most significant laws in Canada’s history, such as the Clarity Act in 2000 and the 2005 Civil Marriage Act, which legalized same-sex marriage nationwide.

This extensive 243-page omnibus bill aims to expedite development initiatives and prevent labor disruptions. Government House leader Steven MacKinnon referred to it as the “focal point” of the fall session.

The bill has faced criticism from labor unions, environmental organizations, and the Assembly of First Nations due to its proposed modifications to consultation practices, impact assessments, and the Labour Code. The legislation covers a wide array of issues, amending or referencing 24 separate acts and regulations.

WATCH | Liberal House leader on C-39:

Economic legislation will be ‘centrepiece’ of fall sitting, says MacKinnon

September 18|

Duration

1:02

Government House leader Steven MacKinnon asserts that MPs will concentrate on a bill designed to ‘protect jobs’ and ‘generate investment in our communities’ when Parliament reconvenes on Monday.

After bills complete their second reading in the House of Commons, they progress to the committee stage, where MPs generally listen to expert testimonies, analyze the text, suggest amendments, and prepare a report. This responsibility typically falls to standing committees, which are permanent bodies that extend across multiple Parliaments.

A legislative committee, however, is a specialized group of parliamentarians appointed solely to evaluate a specific bill, enabling it to bypass other proceedings managed by standing committees.

“The rationale for proceeding in this manner was to create a committee dedicated exclusively to this bill,” MacKinnon stated on Thursday.

He noted that since C-39 intersects “various sectors and departments,” establishing “a committee focused on the entire bill was the appropriate approach.”

MacKinnon emphasized that there was “no other motivation” behind opting for this unusual path and that he is not considering separating C-39 into several bills.

As outlined in the House of Commons Procedure and Practice, the guide for conducting House business, legislative committees are established as needed to scrutinize specific bills, including summoning witnesses and proposing amendments.

Unlike standing committees, however, legislative committees typically do not engage in any additional business, produce extensive reports on the bill under review, or offer recommendations, dissenting, or supplementary opinions on any reports.

Last used on government bill in 2012

The most recent formation of a legislative committee to review a government bill occurred in 2012 during Stephen Harper’s Conservative majority government. At that time, then Industry Minister Christian Paradis reintroduced the Copyright Modernization Act, Bill C-11, which was directed to a legislative committee and ultimately received royal assent a few months later.

The Harper administration also established a legislative committee in 2011 for Bill C-18, which abolished the single-desk monopoly of the Canadian Wheat Board.

Following its introduction in October and a committee review in November, Bill C-18 quickly became law by the end of the year, despite commitments from then Opposition Liberal MPs to delay the process.

Harper’s Conservatives also adopted the same strategy for one of their initial bills after taking office in 2006: the Federal Accountability Act, an omnibus initiative intended to prohibit corporate and union contributions to campaigns and restrict individual donations, among other conflict of interest regulations. They continued this approach in 2007 with C-2, a stringent omnibus crime bill that progressed from introduction to royal assent within four months.

WATCH | Carney responds to labour concerns over C-39:

Major projects bill ‘reinforces the right to strike,’ Carney says

September 22|

Duration

2:04

Prime Minister Mark Carney states that Bill C-39, the Building Canada Strong Act, will enhance the obligation of employers to ‘negotiate in good faith’ and foster transparency regarding labor negotiations.

During Harper’s time in office, legislative committees were established 11 times to expedite government bills. The last instance a Liberal government created such a committee was in 2005 for the Civil Marriage Act, which legalized same-sex marriage throughout Canada. A legislative committee was also formed to facilitate Jean Chrétien’s Clarity Act of 2000, which solidified the process for any future provincial referendum on secession.

Conservative MPs have not disclosed their voting intentions regarding Bill C-39.

“We will take the necessary time to examine the legislation and identify aspects that can be enhanced. Once it reaches the legislative committee, we will propose the amendments needed to actually initiate projects rather than just make promises,” stated Conservative deputy leader Melissa Lantsman.

The composition of the committee is still uncertain. However, with a majority government in place, the Liberals possess sufficient votes to pass it through the House without requiring support from other parties.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Woman hospitalized after bear attack near Whistler backcountry

A woman was hospitalized on Friday following a bear...

David Walliams Under Investigation for Serious Sexual Offenses

On Friday, police in London announced their investigation into...

Prince George Honors Young Hockey Fan Mavrik Turnbull at Ceremony

Residents of Prince George will gather on Saturday to...

SpaceX’s Starship Makes Historic Midair Capture After Space Return

On Saturday, SpaceX's Starship successfully returned to Earth, being...