According to analyst Michael Kovrig, the recent summit between U.S. President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping was characterized more by spectacle than by substantive policy discussions.
During a three-day visit this week, Trump warmly welcomed Xi, culminating in a tea session at the White House.
Following the meetings, Trump referred to them as “very, very productive,” claiming they resulted in “great things for both countries.”
However, Kovrig, a former Canadian diplomat and the senior Asia advisor for the International Crisis Group, argues that the visit yielded little of real value. He further suggests that the perception of Trump’s amicable ties with Xi could be detrimental to U.S. interests and, by extension, Canada’s as well.
This week also commemorates five years since Kovrig was freed from detention in China. His arrest, along with Canadian Michael Spavor, was widely interpreted as retaliation for the 2018 apprehension of Chinese executive Meng Wanzhou in Vancouver, conducted under a U.S. warrant.
Below is an excerpt from his discussion with As It Happens guest host Helen Mann.
Donald Trump claims many positive outcomes emerged from this summit. How accurate is that perspective? And if it is accurate, positive for whom?
I believe the primary beneficiaries are actually Xi Jinping and the Chinese side.
The goal for the Chinese was to host a summit filled with ceremonial grandeur, portraying Xi as a global statesman visiting Washington for the first time in a decade, being treated as an equal by the U.S. president.
Trump likely enjoyed the spectacle as well, as he seeks to project an image of problem-solving through his personal rapport with Xi Jinping.
However, in terms of substantive outcomes, the reality is much less impressive.
You mentioned that Trump likely relishes the grandeur of this visit. But could there be any significant gains for him considering his recent domestic and international challenges over the past several months?
The optics of the event portray a reciprocal visit that positions both leaders as powerful figures, which aligns with Trump’s self-image. Nonetheless, the tangible outcomes appear to be limited mainly to a mere two-month extension of the trade truce.
Both nations have been engaged in a fierce struggle for economic dominance — the U.S. through Trump’s tariffs, which Canada is well acquainted with, and China’s countermeasures involving restrictions on rare earths and critical minerals, resulting in the U.S. retreating.
This dynamic has led to a strategic stalemate, where both countries now focus on minor transactional victories while maintaining a fragile trade truce.

Michael Kovrig, a former Canadian diplomat and senior Asia advisor for the International Crisis Group, endured three years of imprisonment in China. (Barcelona Centre for International Affairs/The Canadian Press)
What do you believe Prime Minister Mark Carney was monitoring during this summit, especially as Canada grapples with not only its trade tensions with the U.S. but also a more assertive China while trying to manage its relationship with Beijing?
The situation is ironic, as much of the U.S. policy establishment holds a hawkish stance towards China, which is understandable given the numerous actions by China that threaten U.S. interests, and consequently, Canadian interests as well.
Yet, the U.S. president’s desire to impress the autocratic leader of China and portray himself as a strongman has undermined much of that hardline policy.
This creates a contradiction wherein the U.S. expects allies like Canada to back it on stringent policies regarding China, while Trump may potentially reach agreements with China that could leave those allies vulnerable.
Carney is likely particularly focused on whether Trump has, or will, consent to any agreements with Xi that could disadvantage Canada, potentially exposing it to repercussions from China, whether they be economic or diplomatic. He will also be vigilant about any U.S.-China trade agreements that might economically disadvantage Canada.
From a strategic standpoint, concerns regarding Taiwan are significant. Trump has delayed a $14 billion [US] arms package intended for Taiwan since May, referring to it as a bargaining tool, which impacts Canada as the country relies on a stable Indo-Pacific for its economic prosperity.
This also puts another democracy, which the U.S. has historically supported, at risk. It sends a message about how the U.S. intends to treat its other allies.

Kovrig asserts that the intention behind Xi’s visit to the White House was to enhance his image in Chinese state media coverage. (Alex Brandon/The Associated Press)
This week marks five years since you were released from detention in China. What insights have you drawn from that experience as you continue to analyze China’s leadership and its global relations?
I left China five years ago after the state party ultimately consented to end my wrongful detention following negotiations. I had been a political pawn in a ruthless strategy to pressure Canada into releasing Huawei Technologies CFO Meng Wanzhou. Ironically, the consequences of that episode are still very relevant today.
Xi Jinping is now in Washington bargaining with the individual who instigated that entire crisis, Donald Trump. Meanwhile, the U.S. government’s legal case against Huawei Technologies has commenced this month in New York City, which connects back to the Meng extradition issue.
This situation is also echoed through the ongoing cases of detainees. While I may have been one of the most notable Canadians detained for political reasons in China, I was not alone. There were others before me, and new cases continue to arise.
China continues to unjustly detain foreign nationals, using them as leverage, whether as hostages or for political aims. This ongoing risk remains, and Canada must collaborate with its allies to encourage China to cease such practices and improve its behavior. Meetings with Xi Jinping, whether attended by Mark Carney or Donald Trump, present opportunities to advocate for the release of such prisoners.
The message to Xi Jinping ought to be straightforward: Abducting and torturing individuals reflects poorly on you. It damages your reputation.
Tag: rewrite-pending


