Alberta Independence Group Unveils Ambitious Transition Plan

Date:

An independence organization has unveiled a “transition plan,” outlining its vision for a potential future in which Albertans may choose to establish themselves as a sovereign nation.

On Thursday, the Alberta Transition Council published a comprehensive 214-page report detailing various proposals regarding what life in Alberta could entail following a favorable vote for independence.

The document addresses several regulations and institutions that the group believes would require negotiation for a successful transition of control to Alberta, including discussions with the federal government.

The proposals range widely, addressing everything from the continuity of social services to air traffic management, the establishment of a new constitution, and the dynamics with First Nations.

Keith Wilson, a lawyer leading the Alberta Transition Council and also affiliated with the independence movement Let Alberta Decide, emphasizes that the goal is to present a framework for a seamless exit from Canada.

“We need to keep in mind that we are not starting anew. The personnel at airports will remain; we are not demolishing the airport. It will still exist,” Wilson stated. “The only change we are making is regarding payroll.”

However, a critic warned that planning for such a transition is premature and labeled the proposal as “unrealistic” given the intricate negotiations that are likely to arise.

“Many of these matters could take years to discuss thoroughly, and some may never reach a resolution,” remarked Errol Mendes, a professor specializing in constitutional and international law at the University of Ottawa.

Certain factors beyond Alberta’s control, report indicates

On October 19, Albertans will cast their votes on whether to remain part of Canada or to pursue a second, binding referendum for separation.

Current polling indicates that only a minority of Albertans supports the idea of secession.

The central premise of the group is to approach the transition not as the formation of a new country “from the ground up.”

“Independence for Alberta would not sever its ties with the rest of Canada,” the report states. “It would alter the legal and governmental framework governing that relationship.”

Two people stand in front of a podium.

Co-leaders of Let Alberta Decide, Keith Wilson (left) and Tanya Clemens, are seen at the launch of the independence organization in Calgary on June 19. (Jeff McIntosh/The Canadian Press)

Simultaneously, the report recognizes that not all aspects are within Alberta’s jurisdiction.

Areas such as debt, mobility, energy infrastructure, pensions, territorial borders, and assets would require negotiations with Canada, First Nations, and other entities.

The report asserts that the outcomes of these negotiations cannot be predetermined or guaranteed.

It also claims that 45 Albertans from various sectors, including banking, law, international trade, First Nations, and policing, contributed to the report’s preparation and review.

However, the names of these contributors have not been disclosed.

Wilson explained that confidentiality measures were taken to protect contributors from potential “cancel culture” or harassment.

“The report will speak for itself. Many Canadians and people globally are becoming skeptical of the ‘experts say’ narrative,” Wilson told CBC News. “Readers will be able to assess it themselves.”

“Each individual has their own life experiences that will allow them to critically evaluate whether the core facts are accurate and if the analysis is logical,” he added.

This document is among several recently released that examine the potential impacts of Alberta’s separation from Canada on everyday life.

From currency to mortgages to military considerations

The introductory section of the report raises several questions.

“How will laws continue? How will the judicial system function? How will wages and pensions be managed? How will financial transactions occur? How will air travel be maintained?”

The group offers some suggestions. For instance, regarding currency, it recommends that Alberta adopt the Canadian dollar at the outset of independence to “minimize disruptions to contracts, pricing, and consumer activities.”

“Other options, such as the U.S. dollar, dual-currency systems, or a future Alberta currency, are considered longer-term alternatives or contingency solutions,” the report states.

U.S. banknotes are depicted in a file photo. The Alberta Transition Council suggests starting with the Canadian dollar while leaving open the possibility of transitioning to the U.S. dollar or a future Alberta currency. (Sertac Kayar/Reuters)

In many instances, definitive solutions are yet to be proposed. Concerning pensions, the group suggests continuing pension payments for the time being and addressing future pension plans and asset transfers later.

The fate of mortgages in the event of a separation vote has been a significant concern leading up to the referendum. Analysts earlier this year indicated to CBC News that numerous uncertainties are involved in what would likely be a complex process.

The plan includes offering the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation the chance to continue its operations in an independent Alberta.

“If they choose not to participate, Alberta would establish its own housing mortgage corporation prior to independence,” Wilson explained. “A transition would occur where this Alberta entity agrees to take on mortgage guarantees to ensure that banks remain stable.”

An aerial photo of a neighbourhood in Edmonton

An aerial view of Lewis Estates in Edmonton. (David Bajer/CBC)

Earlier this week, a separate report from the Calgary-based Canada West Foundation estimated that Alberta’s per capita debt could soar to between $80,000 and $95,000 after separation, compared to $27,000 per person in 2024, based on the anticipated increase in debt burden Alberta might face.

While the Alberta Transition Council does not finalize a specific federal debt figure, it recommends that Canada should not expect Alberta to take on a debt share based merely on population numbers.

“Such a method would overlook the historical fiscal contributions of Albertans, which must be factored into any fair calculation,” the report states.

Moreover, the report does not provide a comprehensive costing analysis of the financial implications associated with independence, promising an accompanying report addressing those details in the near future.

The report also recognizes the constitutionally acknowledged rights of First Nations and their status as treaty partners.

“Reservation land will not automatically change simply because Alberta becomes independent,” the report asserts.

If the independence vote is successful, the report outlines four potential “relationship pathways” for First Nations, including “Option A,” which would allow a First Nation to “maintain its existing relationship with Canada as much as possible.”

Additionally, the report suggests expanding the Alberta Sheriffs into a full provincial police force to replace the RCMP, and proposes the establishment of an initial 2,100-member defense force, comprising 300 full-time members and a separate 1,800-member “territorial force.”

‘I don’t doubt that it’s rosy’

In a report released earlier this week, the Canada West Foundation indicated that negotiations for Alberta’s secession would be intricate, with no guaranteed outcomes.

Establishing an independent Alberta could cost upwards of $200 billion, with ongoing annual costs exceeding $50 billion, according to former Treasury Board senior manager Lennie Kaplan.

Gary Mar, president of the Canada West Foundation, mentioned he has not yet reviewed the complete report from the Alberta Transition Council. However, he believes that both sides of the debate—those wanting to remain in Canada and those advocating for separation—are overly confident in their assumptions.

“We have examined the complexities of both options and drawn conclusions,” Mar said. “While I don’t doubt the optimism in Mr. Wilson’s report, that is precisely what he is promoting.”

A man stands outside.

Gary Mar, president of the Canada West Foundation, commented that both the ‘stay’ and ‘leave’ factions of the debate present overly optimistic future scenarios. (CBC)

Thomas Lukaszuk, leader of the Forever Canadian movement and former deputy premier of Alberta, described the plan as “ridiculous.”

“He is the person who believes he can end a marriage and then show up the next day and ask, ‘What’s for dinner, dear?’” Lukaszuk stated. “That’s not how it operates. This is a divorce.”

Wilson remarked that his organization’s report is optimistic “in the sense that we assume that the federal government, provinces, and First Nations would engage in good-faith negotiations.”

“We understand the services and functions the federal government provides, and we can plan for their transition, just as businesses do when one company acquires another. The customer experience remains unaffected,” he added.

In the coming weeks, Albertans can anticipate additional data and forecasts regarding the province’s future.

This includes a study from the University of Calgary that evaluates the potential costs associated with Alberta’s departure from Canada, commissioned by the provincial government.

This report is expected to be published later this month.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Port Authority Sues After Tanker Collision in New Orleans River Accident

Shortly after a tanker in New Orleans lost control...

Kovrig: Trump’s Xi Summit Sparks Concerns for Canada’s Future

LISTEN | Interview with analyst Michael Kovrig:As It Happens7:07Trump...

Microsoft Faces Major Outage, Disrupting Services for Thousands

A significant outage affecting Microsoft began on Thursday afternoon...

Gérard Depardieu Accepts Conviction for Sexual Assault, Withdraws Appeal

WARNING: This article may be distressing for individuals who...